I finished 'A Small Price to Pay for Birdsong' by KJ Parker last week. It's a short story from the collection Academic Exercises. It felt very much in line with Purple and Black and Blue and Gold, which is a good thing.
There's two main characters, and Parker chooses to follow the less interesting of the two; not sure if this is a twist or not but it certainly makes for some 'uphill' reading. One is a brilliant but apathetic, musician, turned murder; the other his teacher. As the student goes into hiding, never publishing again, for fear of immediate recognition and capture, the teacher passes off his students work as his own and watches his status soar.
It's a good story but in every way, to me at least, feels a bit like an early work newly published. Particularly the end feels off when our bad guy--who has proven to be genius in more areas than just musical composition--just gives up and things come to a very abrupt end.
Music was my primary point of contention. I've covered this ground with other fiction that I've reviewed, but there was horribly off commentary that made me give up on believability. There are some topics that a writer can't casually research and then write about in any convincing way. The story happens in a secondary world that in many ways feels like western Europe. Since it's all made up, I guess I'm supposed to forgive everything. But every reader brings certain knowledge to the table and I couldn't turn my mind off. Reference to a certain page count of manuscript for a symphony made me laugh out loud, as did passages of how music was copied in this time before modern publishing. A composer referencing their own, 'slow movement' as opposed to saying, 'the Andante, or Largo' (what any musically inclined person would have said) made me roll my eyes.
Yeah, it was a good piece of writing and a story that felt like ground work for Blue and Gold, but as I always seem to say when music and literature come together: assume you don't know what you're talking about unless you actually do…
Showing posts with label K.J. Parker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label K.J. Parker. Show all posts
Thursday, October 23, 2014
Friday, July 22, 2011
The Hammer by K. J. Parker
On the surface level, The Hammer feels like a novel. There are characters, backstory, and the framework for tension, but events never seem to become anything more than an outline. It is as if the passage from concept to meaningful, fully-fledged, weighty production never happened, or perhaps such a change happens only it didn't have a chance to mature. I struggled getting through this novel and only did so out of past enjoyment of the authors Purple and Black and Blue and Gold.
So there is a "Colony" a "Company" and an oft mentioned "Home." Oh, and there are also some "Savages…" None of which are ever given proper names a la real life which serves to facilitate my feelings of the book being an elaborate concept. These 'place-holder' names don't have much depth and they seem to be mentioned in the same superficial way you may tell a story to a friend and reference, "that guy at the bar." The 'Company' has a monopoly on all goods used, bought and sold on the "Colony." The colonist pay rent the 'Home' government by way of cattle. There is an out of favor high and once mighty family the met'Oc (I've long since had a dislike for the author's naming conventions) who live on the Colony. They occupy a space marked by near destitution, yet able to inspire fear to all the colonist because one of the met'Oc boys occasionally plays the part of a dangerous lunatic. They are also the only people in the colony with weapons of any sort: swords, and a brace of pistols.
I had a hard time taking any of the characters seriously and though the better part of book deals with Gignomai met'Oc--yes that is his name--he was the most unrealistic of them all. Gig, as he is called, doesn't much like his family and runs away to the other side of the colony which is still within spitting distance of his family. He then decides to start a bloodless revolution against Home and the Company's monopoly by building a factory so the colonist can provide for themselves. Main character or not Gig is as substantial as "that guy at the bar:" a cheap vehicle for a shallow soon-to-be-forgotten anecdote.
Slowly. Ever so slowly, Parker introduces a measure of tension. Things aren't what they seem, motives aren't as they have been stated, and apparently there is a killer inside us all. There are social problems with the met'Oc and the rest of the colonist and eventually we learn of a very twisted family history. The major plot points and revelations felt weak and more like a "hail Mary" pass in an attempt to redeem the previous three-hundred pages of strong, yet unrealized, ideas.
Parker excels in the small exchanges. The one on one conversations where thought or ideas are discussed between characters of conflicting interest are wonderful. These moment are to infrequent and don't have enough bearing on the primary plot to warrant a recommendation to read the book. Previously I had thought Parker to be synonymous with awesome; now I'll proceed with caution concerning any further books by the author that stray from the color-wheel.
Labels:
Commentary,
K.J. Parker,
Reading,
The Hammer
Sunday, March 20, 2011
Blue and Gold by K. J. Parker
I was so ready to not like this book. To say that the last few pages 'redeemed' the story would be a bit too strong, but it did take the last few pages to put things into focus. As with Purple and Black, another short novel by Parker, to discuss the plot would give away the aforementioned redeeming surprised. I won't indulge any spoilers, but the material that moonlights as 'plot' was my primary contention.
Saloninus is the narrator and certainly a unique enough character to merit first person narration. He is one of the more self-serving and quasi larger-than-life characters you'll encounter in any book. He is completely devoid of the scruples of conscience, and while not quite a criminal mastermind he is somewhat of an expert crook among many other things (alchemist, sculptor, poet, academic, etc et al). He is also a liar and extremely entertaining to follow around for one-hundred pages.
Saloninus is in the employ of a prince who gives him unlimited funding in the pursuit of turning base metal into gold. We never see this process happen as Saloninus preaches it's impossibility. We do see Saloninus murder, lie, deceive, steal and be a general not too nice person.
Literary fiction often comes under fire for being beautiful writing, engaging and entertaining with no plot; such was my initial complaint with Blue and Gold. We see the various degrees of Saloninus' character in his past, and present but there was never a reason given, or even one to discern, for his actions. He had a great job with amazing pay and benefits, a pretty wife he didn't like, but it wasn't as if he snapped and went crazy, rather it is presented that his behavior is the only way he could possibly act given his nature. Happily, (not 'luckily' Parker seems too good a writer and in too much control of plot events to say 'luckily') the shared events of Saloninus' life are too much fun to read about and ultimately the novel too short for for me to call it flawed. We are given reasoning and grounding for Saloninus being Saloninus at the end in a fun surprise that Parker seems fond of and expert in conceiving.
The novel is set in an antiquity of Parker's creation but the language used, particularly Saloninus' voice is contemporary. It was a bit jarring at first but I was able to get over today's profanity and vernacular quickly.
Subterranean Press continues to confuse me as they contrast the quality of their books with a lack of copyediting or even general proof reading before printing. It's more than a handful of errors and in a book this short they are all highly visible. Unfortunately, it's a befuddling, consistent issue I've had with Subterranean Press.
Blue and Gold is quick, dirty, and a whole lot of fun. Find a copy. Buy it. Whenever there is nothing worth watching on TV (and when is there?) or it's raining outside, or you're bored and need to kill an hour; read and enjoy.
Labels:
Bad Reading,
Blue and Gold,
Commentary,
Good Times,
K.J. Parker
Sunday, July 11, 2010
Purple and Black by K.J. Parker
In this long short story Parker creatively explores ideas of leadership and power; idealism versus reality; book knowledge against real life experience. Two friends, both around thirty, have recently come into leadership positions and through a series a letters that comprise the narrative they share their triumphs and learning experiences.
The setting seems to be modeled after ancient Rome. Nico is the newly crowned emperor and Phormio is his newly appointed general assigned to quell insurgency in a distant region. Though the book has a feel of antiquity you'll find none of the flowery, affected historical prose of Arturo Pérez-Reverte or other such stylist. The two characters jest, swear and talk politics in language that we hear today; full of fragments, and run-ons, that add realism to their speech.
As the two bicker at the start, the plot slips in very subtly much like the details of their past. Everything about their letters feels real. Both have to deal with morality, one being an active general, the other a politician signing death warrants. By the end, their definition of morals may need a few amendments, yet it is in their seemingly shared philosophy concerning government and power that the story is built on.
It's not the book of military and imperial rule you're expecting, rather a story of relationships and how they develop over time. The story is too delicate to speak of without spoiling. Suffice it to say the phrase, 'a kiss on the lips and a dagger in the heart' comes to mind upon completion.
There is a jarring moment midway through as both characters seem to obsess over someone previously mentioned all of two times. The story shifts drastically and considering the subtly of Parker's narrative, and work's overall brevity, this particular change of direction is extremely blunt.
There is a jarring moment midway through as both characters seem to obsess over someone previously mentioned all of two times. The story shifts drastically and considering the subtly of Parker's narrative, and work's overall brevity, this particular change of direction is extremely blunt.
Not that I'm sensitive to profanity, but I did think it was a bit overused to the detriment of a few passages that may have been strengthened had Parker held back. Readers familiar with Robert Graves I, Claudius and Claudius the God may find a little something extra in Parker's possible homage.
It reads at a fast pace, and can easily be conquered in one sitting. It will stay with you a bit longer. A big thanks to Terry Wenya as I'm now a K.J. Parker fan and have a lot of, hopefully, equally pleasant reading ahead of me.
Labels:
Commentary,
Female Authors,
K.J. Parker,
Purple and Black,
Reading,
Short Fiction
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
